What are the Challenges to the Prevailing Global Order?

9 min read

While speaking at World Economic Forum on 20 January, 2026, the Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney declared that the days of old rule-based order are over and a “new world order” is emerging due to a permanent rupture in the post–Cold War, U.S.-led international framework. He called upon the “middle powers” like Canada to come together and diversify trade to counter aggressive economic coercion and shifting great-power politics. The debate on the crisis of the existing global order is still going on. We need to review what are factors which threaten the prevailing global order.  The rising tendencies of de-globalization and protectionism, disruption of global supply chain, weaponization of technology, trade and loans, weakening of global institutions like WTO, UNSC to name a few, unilateralism amidst chaotic hope of multilateralism, new nationalism riding on the idea of conservativism, retreat from the global responsibilities by established global powers, aggressive behavior by rising powers like China, civil wars in Democratic Republic of Congo, Sudan, and Myanmar, unilateralism in global climate change efforts, and poor showing on the SDGs front in many countries  are some of the important challenges which not only strain the capacity of global system but also threaten the basic norms and institutions underlying the rule based global order.

What is Global Order?

In general terms, the global order means the prevailing structure of relationship and set of rule or norms that provide a framework for interactions among nations and other actors at global level. The global order includes the global institutions and complex web of relationship among nations and other actors including non-state actors, groups and persons.  The noted scholar of IR, Richard Falk (2025) views world order in two senses: Analytical and Prescriptive. “Analytically, world order refers to the arrangement of power and authority that provides the framework for the conduct of diplomacy and world politics on a global scale. Prescriptively, world order refers to a preferred arrangement of power and authority that is associated with the realization of such values as peace, economic growth and equity, human rights, and environmental quality and sustainability.

The prevailing global order was put in place following the WWII. In brief, the post-WWII world system has been characterized by the following features:

  1. The sovereign nation states as primary actors of the system, though later many global institutions and non-state actors too have joined the world order as actors. Among the global actors, the UN system occupies the important place.
  2. In spite of prescribed rule of sovereign equality, the major powers have played leading role in the functioning of the world order.
  3. There has been plethora of global norms and institutions for the functioning of global system, but their enforcement has been slack due to sovereignty of nations and unilateralism of major powers
  4. On prescriptive side, the world order aim to achieve peace and stability and cooperation among nations by enhancing its mandate to protection of human rights, making provision for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), facilitating global trade and development and addressing the emerging global challenges like climate change and other environmental concerns.

Contemporary Challenges to the Global Order

While the global order was under stress due to many issues like China’s assertiveness and ongoing conflicts like Ukraine and Gaza and many civil conflicts across the world, the policies of second Trump administration have hastened the debate as well as decline of global order in our times. It matters because the US is still a predominant major power and largest economy of the world. The US policies have deep impact on the political and economic subsystems of the global order. Trump administration has shown the tendency of reducing every issue to economic gain under its promise of Make America Great Again (MAGA). Trump has withdrawn from global commitments like climate change and threatened to withdraw from WHO and has obstructed the defied the norms of other global institutions like WTO and International Criminal Court. Not only that he has weaponised trade by announcing unilateral tariff hikes against all countries, placed undue restriction on immigration, and warned Europe to take care of their own security and take over of Gaza to develop it as a tourist resort. Trump administration still claims to be global power but its actions are signs of retreat from global responsibilities.

  1. Lack of Consensus on Fundamental Norms of Global Governance

World order can be sustained only if there are certain norms and there is consensus among members to observe these norms. The fundamental norms of the global order like respect for human rights, democracy, rule-based order, sovereign equality, non-aggression, non-intervention, collective security and so. Since the rise of China, the growing polarization between the western world and emerging China, these norms are contested intensely. China is not alone. For different reasons other nations like Russia, North Korea and Iran have also in strategic alliance with China.

  • Rising Protectionism Among Nations

Global protectionism is on rise. If China is a threat to the rule-based order, the west is pioneer in protectionism in terms of trade and immigration. The irony is that the very nations which supported free trade and flow of man power are resorting to protectionism against this free flow of goods services and manpower. In 2023, the European Union announced Border Carbon Adjustment Mechanism (BCAM) which imposes extra tariff on the import from other countries is they do not meet the EU carbon emission norms. This mechanism would be fully effective from 1 January, 2026.  The introduction of the CBAM has a significant impact on businesses importing goods into the EU. India and other countries have protested against this measure as it restricts free trade with EU. The immigration and mobility restrictions are also sign of protectionism. The second Trump administration has defied all global norms on trade by announcing unilaterally exorbitant rates of tariff against all its trading partners including India and China.

  • Failure and Retreat of Globalization

Since early 1990s, the globalization and economic liberalization have been the mainstay of global trade order. Though initially, many developing countries hesitatingly accepted this new economic order, due to its potential pitfalls. Leading global economist Joseph Stiglitz said that it has certain benefits, but it also has significant downsides, mainly for developing countries and poor sections of society. He argued globalization for exacerbating inequality, undermining government’s ability to implement policies that promote economic development, and potentially causing environmental degradation. Amidst increasing tendencies of protectionism, nationalism (Make America Great Again) and unilateralism undermine the globalization.

  • Weaponization of Trade, Technology, and Supply Chain

The most disturbing trend for global order in last one decade has been the mixing of strategic issues and economic issues by nations in a single policy framework. Nations resort to weaponization of trade, technology transfer and supply of goods to achieve strategic objectives. The US and China are ahead of others in weaponizing trade technology and supply of goods and services. America has banned many Chinese technology companies including Huawei and HTE from operating in US in 2019 citing security concerns. The European partners of the US have followed suit and the move almost wiped out the Chinese company’s global smartphone business. China does not hesitate in weaponizing supply chain and trade. In April, 2025, China has banned 12 American tech companies including Phonotics Corporation from exporting goods to China on the security of concerns. If trade and technology items are weaponized, the global supply chain is under strain due to various restriction imposed by countries on the supply of important items like critical minerals. The US and China are the two largest economies of the world and one can easily guess the consequences of trade war between them on the global economy and global order.

  • Rise of Neonationalism and Rise of Conservatism

Since last one decade or so, there has appreciable rise in the conservative forces and parties in Europe and other parts of the world. This is the outcome of ideology of neonationalism and populism followed by many countries. The conservatism and neonationalism support inward looking policies and national agenda at the cost of global commitment and responsibilities. In countries like US, Italy, Germany, France Hungary, Austria, Switzerland, Denmark, Belgium and Spain and other countries, the conservative and nationalist forces have gained ground. According a study by the BBC (2019) ‘Nationalism has always been a feature across Europe’s political spectrum but there has been a recent boom in voter support for right-wing and populist parties.’ In some countries like Hungary, conservatives and nationalist enjoy nearly 50 percent popular support.  President Trump is in fact launching and neoconservative agenda under the banner of MAGA. The forces of neonationalism, conservatism and populism are weakening the foundation of global order due to their nationalistic agenda. During the refugee crisis many European countries banned the entry of immigrants citing it as threat to Christian values and European culture.

  • Rising Threat to Multilateralism

Multilateralism is the process of organizing relations among nations on the basis of collective interests. The multilateralism is based on certain principles like, indivisibility of interests among participants, a commitment to diffused reciprocity, and a system of dispute settlement intended to enforce a particular mode of behaviour. The UN system is based on the idea of Multilateralism and collective security. Multilateralism is essential condition for the foundation and sustenance of global order. However, the tendencies of unilateralism are gaining ground in the contemporary world, in spite of call for strengthening multilateralism by India and other countries. The Unilateral policies by China in the Indo-pacific region and by the Trump Administration pose significant challenge to multilateralism in the present context. The unilateral actions by major powers erode not only the global norms but the very credibility of global institutions like UN. While multilateralism is increasingly challenged by regional power rivalries, institutional stagnation, and emerging global threats. The UNSC, as a vital international space for global security and multilateralism, still faces much criticism and scrutiny for its decision-making process, limited representation of emerging powers, and veto disparities.

Thus, there are strains in the prevailing global order, but the emergence of the new global order anchored on the interactive dynamics of middle power may take time.  

Leave a Reply